Two views: how Google Ads spend relates to the record month, and where MPS sits among 16 competitors in search.
SEMrush estimates of each site's Google search traffic, October 2024 through October 2026. These are outside-in estimates, not the sites' own analytics, so treat them as direction and scale rather than exact counts.
Of 17 sites tracked (MPS plus 16 competitors), by estimated visits from Google search results in October 2026.
From about 660 to roughly 1,500 monthly visits. Keywords ranking grew from 1.9K to 2.7K, and the value of that traffic nearly doubled.
About 27K visits a month and $80K in traffic value. Cleanroom World is the other riser, doubling traffic in a year on fewer keywords.
GoToPac lost about 40% of search traffic and stopped buying search ads in August 2025. Angstrom lost about 80%, which looks like a site migration that went badly.
Pick what to compare, then click any row in the table to add or remove that site from the chart. MPS is always shown in blue.
| # |
|---|
SEMrush estimates, not analytics. Paid figures cover Google text search ads only; Shopping and Performance Max spend is not visible here, so anyone running those is understated. "Value of search traffic" is SEMrush's estimate of what the same clicks would cost in Google Ads. Monthly figures are the mean of SEMrush's daily readings for that month; October 2026 covers the 1st through the 15th.
From the account change history, August through mid-October 2026. Paid visitors started viewing fewer products and buying less the week of August 24, and attributed conversions have been about half their early-August level since. These are the edits that line up with that.
Wipes/Mops, Furniture and Softwall moved from Maximize Conversions to Maximize Conversion Value on Sep 22. Gloves PMax followed on Oct 6 and Apparel on Oct 7. The ROAS targets were also removed from PMax Cleanrooms (850%) on Oct 6 and Hardwall (800%) on Oct 7.
Why it matters: each switch restarts the learning period. Value-based bidding is now steering by the conversion values that are under-reported right now. If sales keep landing as Direct, the algorithm will pull spend away from campaigns that are actually working. Removing the ROAS targets also means nothing caps what Google pays per click.
On Oct 6, Request Quotes was removed from Gloves PMax, so it optimized on purchases only, then it was re-added on Oct 12. The new Search campaign had phone calls added on Oct 8 and removed on Oct 12. Gloves numbers for Oct 6–12 won't compare cleanly with anything before or after.
It has a $75/day budget, AI Max on, and Gloves, Wipes and Mops ad groups, with about 80 keyword changes on Oct 6–8. It targets the same searches as Gloves PMax and Wipes/Mops PMax, so those campaigns will compete for the same queries and credit will split between them.
This campaign may be the response to the Gloves 0.5x finding. If so, it's built on a number that's probably an attribution problem.
Sales-Shopping (standard Shopping) was paused on Sep 22 and Feed Only PMax switched on the same day. Feed Only was then paused on Oct 1, so neither has run since then. That matches the drop in GA4 Paid Shopping sessions from 1,379 to 572.
These were turned on for Softwall (Aug 26), Apparel (created Aug 11, URL expansion on) and the new Search campaign. They let Google pick landing pages and write ad text. Auto-Apply removed a Softwall exact-match keyword ([modular softwall cleanrooms]) on Oct 8, so auto-applied recommendations are also turned on.
Hardwall, Softwall and PMax Cleanrooms, your highest-ROAS campaigns, were cut to $50–75 on Aug 11 and restored on Aug 21. That partly explains the uneven August weeks.
All edits come from a personal Gmail (larson55337), and a second personal Gmail (sam.larose097) was given Admin access on Aug 3. If both are known MPS or contractor accounts, that's fine. If not, it's worth confirming, since an Admin can change billing and remove users.