Through September, Haferman's website produced 860 leads, 372 of them new-business requests, against 841 and 364 over the same nine months of 2025. Underneath that flat line, the year had three distinct chapters: a strong first quarter with organic search at a peak, a spring and summer in which Google began answering Haferman's how-to articles on its own results page and blog traffic fell by two thirds, and a September in which the Google Ads campaign drifted into display placements and paid calls halved. Through all of it the phone outperformed the website form: 3,029 tracked phone contacts (1,626 from website visitors, 1,403 from the Google Business Profile) against 860 forms, about three and a half to one. This review sets the full-year context for the 90-day plan.
Organic search peaked. Search Console clicks ran 2,077, 2,073 and 2,206 a month, the best three months in the data, with an average position of 8 in March. Nearly all of it was how-to traffic: standing water in the salt tank, low pressure, salt bridges.
Leads were strong. 108, 124 and 89 website leads; February was inflated by a bot-spam episode (46 leads with no channel). Paid calls ran 98–108 a month at about $1,356 of spend.
Google Ads conversions looked their best (163 in January) before the ServiceTitan import stopped reporting in March; the drop that followed in the Ads dashboard is partly a measurement change, not a lead change.
Search clicks fell every month from 2,206 in March to 907 in August, and average position slid from 8 to 18. Organic visits to the how-to articles went from 1,727 in January to 635 in August, down 64%. Google's AI Overviews now answer those questions in place; Haferman is cited in 20 of them but no longer gets the click.
The pages that sell did not fall. Organic visits to the home, product, service and contact pages held between 459 and 674 a month all year. Organic callers held too: 107 in April, 85 in August.
Fair Season (July–September, $1,810) put Haferman in front of 561,380 people on Facebook and produced six QR-code water-test leads.
The week of August 31 the Performance Max campaign began serving display and YouTube placements. Impressions tripled to 30,065, clicks rose, and calls from paid visitors fell from 102 to 50 at the same budget. Cost per paid contact went from $13 to $26. A smaller version of the same drift happened in April (23,971 impressions) and cost less; September's was larger and landed on the busiest season.
Restoring the search placements is the first item in the 90-day plan.
The Business Profile grew while the blog shrank: 1,403 calls, 1,890 direction requests and 1,566 website clicks year to date, with September the best month for calls (212) and profile views (5,352).
Phone contacts ran 3.5 to one over forms. Call tracking recorded 1,626 website-driven calls, 1,048 of them first-time callers. Earlier briefs counted only the forms; that undercounted the year.
Reviews kept pace: 247 new reviews, 243 of them five-star, and half of them name the technician who came.
One selling page (the home page) and eight troubleshooting articles. The articles still earn visits; they earn fewer each month and almost no leads. The plan keeps them, restructured as question-and-answer pages the AI engines can cite with Haferman's name attached, and puts the new effort into pages that convert.
Position Tracking covers 171 keywords, most of them troubleshooting phrases chosen in 2025 for the blog. It sees Haferman cited on repair questions and sees Culligan cited on buying questions, because those are the terms on the list. It does not see the local buying searches that matter most now ("water softener installation Lakeville," "who services Kinetico near me"), and it cannot see what ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google AI Mode answer when someone asks who to call.
Two changes, both in the 90-day plan. Expand the Position Tracking list to the buying and local terms by county, so share of voice is measured on the searches the rebuild targets. And run the two SEMrush AI tests (AI Visibility Tracking, AI PR) for two months, so the November and December briefs show whether Haferman is recommended on buying questions and which sources the assistants draw on.
The goal for the rebuild: be cited on the buying questions the way Haferman already is on the repair questions. Question-and-answer formatting, structured data and the county pages are built for that.
New-business leads split the same way: organic 162, direct 124, paid 63, referral 20. Direct is mostly people who already know the name; it includes radio, print and word of mouth, which is why tracked numbers on those channels are in the plan.
Only four website visits all year came referred from kinetico.com. Kinetico's referred leads arrive through its dealer system, not the website, so the decline Kinetico reported is not visible here; we still need those monthly counts from January 2025 to size it.
Counting forms alone, 2026 looks flat. Counting every tracked contact, the year produced 3,889 leads and service contacts: 860 forms, 1,626 website calls and 1,403 profile calls. Those calls include current customers booking service, which is why the ServiceTitan connection in the plan matters: it is the only way to say how many of them became jobs. Until then, the two numbers that stay on the first page of every brief are first-time phone contacts and new-business forms.
122 posts, 770,521 content views, 33 new followers (554 total). Views come in bursts when posts are boosted: $2,007 in boosts this year, almost all of it the Fair Season campaign in July–September, which reached 561,380 people. Unboosted posts average about 40 views.
The best-read posts of the year were benefit-led: whole-home water treatment explained (67,739 views, boosted), PFAS in Apple Valley (16,996), the Chaska wellness expo (16,792), and "a real person answers" (8,913). That pattern is what the always-on campaign in the plan buys every month instead of in bursts.
Instagram reached 18,929 accounts in April when a post was boosted and under 1,000 in most other months, with 5 website clicks all year.
247 new Google reviews this year (243 five-star; 238 in the same months of 2025), 1,631 in total at 4.9. Replies: 72% of this year's reviews answered, 97% in the last 90 days.
Half of the reviews since 2023 name the technician who came; a third say friendly; a quarter say he explained the system or answered every question. Almost none mention the product by feature. That is the brand, and the messaging guide is built from it.
By month: Jan 27 · Feb 23 · Mar 32 · Apr 26 · May 28 · Jun 27 · Jul 36 · Aug 27 · Sep 21.
How-to traffic went to AI answers; the selling pages and the local pages held or grew. The rebuild's county pages, booking page and restructured product pages are aimed at the buying searches Haferman does not rank for today.
Restricting Performance Max to search, adding a Search campaign on the terms that surface the profile, and feeding CallRail's calls into Google are the no-cost items that put paid calls back in the 90–100 range.
1,403 calls and 1,890 direction requests with no booking link and no posting schedule. Both are in the plan at no cost; the Local Services Ads test puts a paid call button above the same map.
Forms were 22% of contacts this year. Cost per lead, the November and December targets, and the December budget decision are all stated in calls and first-time contacts; the ServiceTitan connection adds booked jobs behind them.